Member Features

Find Real Estate Bargain!

  • Full foreclosure details

  • Home value, equity and ownership info

  • Find homes priced below market

  • Get full access with a FREE Account

Already a member?

$1,758,800

Listing Price

5beds

4baths

3,259sqft

15,499sqft lot

40 Prospect Ave, Garden City, NY 11530

Member Features

Find Real Estate Bargain!

  • Full foreclosure details

  • Home value, equity and ownership info

  • Find homes priced below market

  • Get full access with a FREE Account

Already a member?

For Sale

Off Market

Single Family

Home type

584.28

Price / sqft

1938

Year built

Home Details

Welcome to 40 Prospect Avenue, a beautifully updated 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath center hall brick colonial located in the Eastern section of Garden City. This meticulously maintained home offers 2, 800 interior square feet of living space and offers a perfect blend of classic elegance and modern comfort. The first floor features a gracious entry foyer, spacious living room with gas fireplace, formal dining room, large eat-in kitchen, study, family room and powder room. The upstairs has a primary bedroom with en-suite bathroom, 3 additional bedrooms and a full bath and separate guest quarters with a private bedroom and full bath. Some highlights of the home include updated kitchen and bathrooms, central air conditioning and central heating, in-ground sprinklers, 2-zone heat, cedar closet, finished basement and a 2-car attached garage. Step outside into your personal oasis... the backyard beckons with an in-ground heated pool, complemented with an expansive patio area complete with a covered dining area and barbecue space. This exceptional residence is conveniently located a short distance from the LIRR, shopping, restaurants, schools and the park. Don't miss this one!

Interior Details

Square Feet
  • 3259

Bedrooms
  • 5

Bathrooms
  • 4

Heating
  • Has Heating:

    Yes

  • Heating Type:

    Central

Cooling
  • Has Cooling:

    Yes

  • Cooling Type:

    Central

Fuel
  • Has Fuel:

    Yes

  • Fuel Type:

    Oil

Basement
  • Has Basement:

    No

  • Basement Type:

    Full

Flooring
  • Has Flooring:

    No

  • Flooring Type:

    N/A

Fireplace
  • Has Fireplace:

    Yes

  • Fireplace Type:

    N/A

Property Details

Lot Size
  • 15499

Water
  • Yes

Sewer
  • Yes

Parking
  • Type:

    Garage, Attached

  • Location:

    N/A

  • Status:

    N/A

  • Number of Spaces:

    2

Deck
  • No

Patio
  • No

Fence
  • No

Pool
  • No

Porch
  • Yes

Stoop
  • No

Breezeway
  • No

Construction Details

Number of Stories
  • 2

Style
  • Colonial

Exterior
  • Brick

Foundation
  • N/A

Roof
  • N/A

Roofing Material
  • Slate

Tax History

Year

Amount

Land

Improvement

Percent Change

Assessment

2019

$21,766

$459

$670

--%

$1,129

2019

$21,766

$1,479

$714

--%

$2,193

2018

$19,494

$1,479

$714

--%

$2,193

2016

$17,396

$1,479

$714

--%

$2,193

2016

$17,396

$1,479

$714

--%

$2,193

2014

$15,251

$1,479

$714

--%

$2,193

2014

$15,251

$1,479

$714

--%

$2,193

2012

$14,193

$1,479

$1,052

--%

$2,531

percent-home-icon

Average Home Price in 11530

Nearby Properties

Zip Code

Price

Bed

Bath

Sqft

Lot

Sold Date

$3,399,000

5 Beds

4 Baths

3,696 Sqft

27,600 Lot (sqft)

Sold 10/05/2026

$1,975,000

4 Beds

4 Baths

2,992 Sqft

7,560 Lot (sqft)

Sold 09/29/2026

$1,499,000

-- Beds

1 Baths

3,228 Sqft

7,500 Lot (sqft)

Sold 07/10/2025

$1,899,000

4 Beds

3 Baths

3,269 Sqft

15,451 Lot (sqft)

Sold 09/29/2026

$1,775,000

-- Beds

4.5 Baths

3,100 Sqft

19,998 Lot (sqft)

Sold 07/10/2025

$1,789,000

5 Beds

3 Baths

2,846 Sqft

12,301 Lot (sqft)

Sold 09/29/2026

$1,758,800

5 Beds

4 Baths

3,259 Sqft

15,499 Lot (sqft)

Sold 10/05/2026

$1,999,000

4 Beds

4 Baths

2,814 Sqft

15,499 Lot (sqft)

Sold 10/05/2026

$1,895,000

4 Beds

4 Baths

3,138 Sqft

11,252 Lot (sqft)

Sold 09/29/2026

percent-home-icon

Calculators

Mortgage

Mortgage Calculator

Calculate your monthly mortgage payments.
Household Income
70,000
$
Home price
1,758,800
$
Down payment
351,760
$
Mortgage Rate
6.5
%
Loan Term
Property Tax Rate
1.1
%
Homeowner's Insurance (Annual)
10,552.80
$
HOA (Monthly)
0
$
PMI
0
$
$11,385
Your Payment
Total Monthly Payment:$11,385
Percent of Income:195%
Affordable:No

Details for 40 PROSPECT AVE

Property Debt

Foreclosure Contact Details