
Member Features
Find Real Estate Bargain!
Full foreclosure details
Home value, equity and ownership info
Find homes priced below market
Get full access with a FREE Account
Already a member?
$3,962,044
Sold Price3beds
4baths
4,174sqft
87,120sqft lot
28 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Member Features
Find Real Estate Bargain!
Full foreclosure details
Home value, equity and ownership info
Find homes priced below market
Get full access with a FREE Account
Already a member?
Recently Sold
Off Market
Home type
Price / sqft
Year built
Home Details
Interior Details
4174
3
4
Has Heating:
Yes
Heating Type:
Hot Water
Has Cooling:
No
Cooling Type:
N/A
Has Fuel:
Yes
Fuel Type:
Oil
Has Basement:
No
Basement Type:
Full
Has Flooring:
No
Flooring Type:
N/A
Has Fireplace:
Yes
Fireplace Type:
N/A
Property Details
87120
Yes
Yes
Type:
N/A
Location:
N/A
Status:
N/A
Number of Spaces:
N/A
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
Construction Details
Colonial
Wood
N/A
N/A
N/A
Tax History
Year
Amount
Land
Improvement
Percent Change
Assessment
2020
$11,913
$450,000
$1,503,000
--%
$1,953,000
0
$0
$450,000
$1,493,000
--%
$1,943,000
2017
$11,261
$675,000
$1,214,000
--%
$1,889,000
2016
$11,105
$675,000
$1,148,000
--%
$1,823,000
2015
$10,736
$642,900
$1,125,100
--%
$1,768,000
2014
$10,527
$642,900
$1,057,100
--%
$1,700,000
2013
$10,246
$696,400
$999,600
--%
$1,696,000
Average Home Price in 11964
Nearby Properties
Zip Code
Price
Bed
Bath
Sqft
Lot
Sold Date
$3,962,044
$3,962,044
3 Beds
4 Baths
4,174 Sqft
87,120 Lot (sqft)
Sold 10/28/2026
$4,169,890
$4,169,890
4 Beds
4.5 Baths
3,676 Sqft
20,038 Lot (sqft)
Sold 07/07/2026






