Member Features

Find Real Estate Bargain!

  • Full foreclosure details

  • Home value, equity and ownership info

  • Find homes priced below market

  • Get full access with a FREE Account

Already a member?

$3,962,044

Sold Price

3beds

4baths

4,174sqft

87,120sqft lot

28 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Member Features

Find Real Estate Bargain!

  • Full foreclosure details

  • Home value, equity and ownership info

  • Find homes priced below market

  • Get full access with a FREE Account

Already a member?

Recently Sold

Off Market

Single Family

Home type

949.22

Price / sqft

1988

Year built

Home Details

Interior Details

Square Feet
  • 4174

Bedrooms
  • 3

Bathrooms
  • 4

Heating
  • Has Heating:

    Yes

  • Heating Type:

    Hot Water

Cooling
  • Has Cooling:

    No

  • Cooling Type:

    N/A

Fuel
  • Has Fuel:

    Yes

  • Fuel Type:

    Oil

Basement
  • Has Basement:

    No

  • Basement Type:

    Full

Flooring
  • Has Flooring:

    No

  • Flooring Type:

    N/A

Fireplace
  • Has Fireplace:

    Yes

  • Fireplace Type:

    N/A

Property Details

Lot Size
  • 87120

Water
  • Yes

Sewer
  • Yes

Parking
  • Type:

    N/A

  • Location:

    N/A

  • Status:

    N/A

  • Number of Spaces:

    N/A

Deck
  • No

Patio
  • No

Fence
  • No

Pool
  • No

Porch
  • Yes

Stoop
  • No

Breezeway
  • No

Construction Details

Number of Stories
  • 2

Style
  • Colonial

Exterior
  • Wood

Foundation
  • N/A

Roof
  • N/A

Roofing Material
  • N/A

Tax History

Year

Amount

Land

Improvement

Percent Change

Assessment

2020

$11,913

$450,000

$1,503,000

--%

$1,953,000

0

$0

$450,000

$1,493,000

--%

$1,943,000

2017

$11,261

$675,000

$1,214,000

--%

$1,889,000

2016

$11,105

$675,000

$1,148,000

--%

$1,823,000

2015

$10,736

$642,900

$1,125,100

--%

$1,768,000

2014

$10,527

$642,900

$1,057,100

--%

$1,700,000

2013

$10,246

$696,400

$999,600

--%

$1,696,000

percent-home-icon

Average Home Price in 11964

Nearby Properties

Zip Code

Price

Bed

Bath

Sqft

Lot

Sold Date

$3,962,044

3 Beds

4 Baths

4,174 Sqft

87,120 Lot (sqft)

Sold 10/28/2026

$4,169,890

4 Beds

4.5 Baths

3,676 Sqft

20,038 Lot (sqft)

Sold 07/07/2026

percent-home-icon

Calculators

Mortgage

Mortgage Calculator

Calculate your monthly mortgage payments.
Household Income
70,000
$
Home price
3,962,044
$
Down payment
792,408.8
$
Mortgage Rate
6.5
%
Loan Term
Property Tax Rate
1.1
%
Homeowner's Insurance (Annual)
23,772.26
$
HOA (Monthly)
0
$
PMI
0
$
$25,647
Your Payment
Total Monthly Payment:$25,647
Percent of Income:440%
Affordable:No

Details for 28 S MENANTIC RD

Property Debt

Foreclosure Contact Details