Shelter Island, NY Home Values & Market Trends
Real estate market trends reflect that there have been 58 transactions over the past year in Shelter Island. The median value for residential home transactions that occurred over the previous year is $1,309,544. The number of current listings in Shelter Island is 2, and the percentage of properties for sale in the city is 2.00%. Shelter Island, NY currently has 13 properties in foreclosure, 0 bank owned properties, 0 properties headed for auction, and 2 properties for sale.
Shelter Island, NY Real Estate Market Overview
| Zip | Median Est. Value |
|---|---|
| 11964 | $ 1,309,544 $ 1,006/sqft |
Housing Market Summary for Shelter Island, NY
| Oct 2025 | October 2026 | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median Listing Price | $0 | $1.9M | - |
| Median Sold Price | $1.5M | $1.9M | 27.14% |
| Homes For Sale | 1 | 2 | 100.00% |
| Homes Sold | 34 | 29 | -14.71% |
Price Per Square Foot
On an average, Single Family homes cost $33 more per sqft than Condos. In comparison with sales price/sqft last week, list price/sqft of Single Family homes increased by 1.93% whereas, list price/sqft of Condos increased by 9.38%.
Recently Sold Homes
Explore recent offers and recently sold homes in Shelter Island, NY
Browse Homes in Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island home values range from $805,685 to $16,367,459. The median estimated value of a home in Shelter Island is $1,309,544. The median list price of a home is 1,895,000, and the total count of properties in the city is 55.
- Pre-ForeclosurePre-foreclosure homes account for 23.64% of all residential properties in Shelter Island, NY with 11964 containing 13 pre-foreclosures, the highest number of pre-foreclosure properties in a single zip. There is 1 zips within Shelter Island, NY; of that zips, the estimated home value for pre-foreclosure homes ranges from $10,258,050 in 11964 to the lowest home value of $805,685 in 11964.
- Bank OwnedThe median estimated home value of bank owned homes (REO properties) in Shelter Island, NY ranges from the highest value of $0 in N/A to the lowest value of $0 in N/A. Bank owned homes and properties account for 0% of properties in Shelter Island, NY. There is 1 zips within Shelter Island, NY; N/A containing 0 REO properties, has the highest number of bank owned properties in a single zip.
- AuctionsN/A has 0 auction properties, the highest number of properties going to auction in a single zip in the state of Shelter Island, NY. Auction homes and other auction properties account for 0% of all properties in Shelter Island, NY. There is 1 zips within Shelter Island, NY; of that zips, the median estimated home value for homes going to auction ranges from $0 in N/A to the lowest value of $0 in N/A.
Compare Nearby Cities
More Real Estate Resources for Shelter Island, NY
Guide for Shelter Island, NY
New York Foreclosure Laws
Foreclosure is a term that can sometimes lead to confusion for those looking to make a real estate investment. In simple terms, it refers to the process where a lender takes possession of a property after the owner fails to keep up with their mortgage payments. When it comes to land, this means that buyers […]
Descubre todo lo que necesitas saber sobre cómo comprar una casa en ejecución hipotecaria.
Learn how to buy a foreclosed home in Chicago, Illinois.