Sullivan County, NY Home Values & Market Trends

The median home price in Sullivan County, NY is $359,147. There were 1,561 home sales in Sullivan County, NY over the past 12 months. The median residential Sullivan County, NY home value for transactions over the previous year is $265,000. The number of current listings in Sullivan County, NY is 1,613, and the percentage of properties for sale is 1613.00%. The county has 234 foreclosures, 1 bank owned properties, 0 headed for auction, and 1,613 properties for sale.

Sullivan County, NY Real Estate Market Overview

CityMedian Est. ValueCityMedian Est. Value
Monticello

$ 335,681

$ 228/sqft

Highland Lake

$ 413,899

$ 280/sqft

Wurtsboro

$ 374,999

$ 227/sqft

White Lake

$ 537,320

$ 213/sqft

Liberty

$ 277,883

$ 180/sqft

North Branch

$ 245,000

$ 195/sqft

Rock Hill

$ 435,000

$ 233/sqft

Bethel

$ 404,630

$ 332/sqft

Livingston Manor

$ 382,360

$ 239/sqft

Yulan

$ 300,322

$ 259/sqft

Bloomingburg

$ 496,914

$ 253/sqft

Fallsburg

$ 292,910

$ 181/sqft

Glen Spey

$ 430,366

$ 253/sqft

Smallwood

$ 317,800

$ 229/sqft

Narrowsburg

$ 449,000

$ 288/sqft

Fremont Center

$ 346,400

$ 268/sqft

Woodridge

$ 259,000

$ 170/sqft

Pond Eddy

$ 416,386

$ 234/sqft

Roscoe

$ 380,624

$ 243/sqft

Mongaup Valley

$ 311,220

$ 238/sqft

Woodbourne

$ 386,048

$ 248/sqft

Long Eddy

$ 133,383

$ 95/sqft

Jeffersonville

$ 383,935

$ 223/sqft

Youngsville

$ 469,500

$ 332/sqft

Cochecton

$ 346,137

$ 220/sqft

Lake Huntington

$ 298,118

$ 192/sqft

Swan Lake

$ 383,023

$ 242/sqft

Kenoza Lake

$ 203,853

$ 183/sqft

Eldred

$ 332,910

$ 228/sqft

Westbrookville

$ 320,730

$ 261/sqft

Barryville

$ 425,000

$ 247/sqft

Glen Wild

$ --

$ --

Callicoon

$ 391,331

$ 242/sqft

Claryville

$ 586,252

$ 197/sqft

Forestburgh

$ 369,211

$ 260/sqft

Harris

$ 450,000

$ 170/sqft

Kiamesha Lake

$ 225,000

$ 196/sqft

Hortonville

$ --

$ --

Grahamsville

$ 296,135

$ 213/sqft

Phillipsport

$ --

$ --

Neversink

$ 392,450

$ 234/sqft

Kauneonga Lake

$ --

$ --

Parksville

$ 326,077

$ 263/sqft

Burlingham

$ --

$ --

Hurleyville

$ 351,546

$ 195/sqft

Hankins

$ --

$ --

Ferndale

$ 397,448

$ 272/sqft

White Sulphur Springs

$ --

$ --

Loch Sheldrake

$ 345,432

$ 224/sqft

Obernburg

$ --

$ --

Mountain Dale

$ 331,568

$ 169/sqft

Callicoon Center

$ --

$ --

South Fallsburg

$ 383,331

$ 257/sqft

Summitville

$ --

$ --

See More

Housing Market Summary for Sullivan County, NY

Oct 2025October 2026Change
Median Listing Price$350K$365K4.29%
Median Sold Price$327.4K$317.9K-2.92%
Homes For Sale1,1261,61243.16%
Homes Sold840692-17.62%
Price
$/Sqft
Homes For Sale
0
0

Price Per Square Foot

On an average, Single Family homes cost $33 more per sqft than Condos. In comparison with sales price/sqft last week, list price/sqft of Single Family homes increased by 1.93% whereas, list price/sqft of Condos increased by 9.38%.

0
0

Browse Homes in Sullivan County, NY

Sullivan County, NY home values range from $35,085 to $8,000,000. Fallsburg is the priciest city with a median listing home price of $675,000, and Glen Wild is most affordable with average house prices of around $130,000.

Foreclosure
There are 54 cities within Sullivan County, NY; within these cities, the median estimated home value for homes in foreclosure ranges from $711,323 in Woodridge to the lowest value of $80,046 in Woodridge. Foreclosure homes account for 8.00% of properties in Sullivan County, NY with Monticello containing 50 foreclosures, the highest number of foreclosure properties in a single city.
  • Pre-Foreclosure
    Pre-foreclosure homes account for 8.41% of all residential properties in Sullivan County, NY with Monticello containing 50 pre-foreclosures, the highest number of pre-foreclosure properties in a single city. There are 54 cities within Sullivan County, NY; of those cities, the estimated home value for pre-foreclosure homes ranges from $746,763 in Claryville to the lowest home value of $80,046 in Woodridge.
  • Bank Owned
    The median estimated home value of bank owned homes (REO properties) in Sullivan County, NY ranges from the highest value of $148,016 in Barryville to the lowest value of $148,016 in Barryville. Bank owned homes and properties account for 0.04% of properties in Sullivan County, NY. There are 54 cities within Sullivan County, NY; Barryville containing 1 REO properties, has the highest number of bank owned properties in a single city.
  • Auctions
    N/A has 0 auction properties, the highest number of properties going to auction in a single city in the state of Sullivan County, NY. Auction homes and other auction properties account for 0% of all properties in Sullivan County, NY. There are 54 cities within Sullivan County, NY; of those cities, the median estimated home value for homes going to auction ranges from $0 in N/A to the lowest value of $0 in N/A.
Homes for Sale
Homes and properties that are actively listed for sale account for 58.19% of residential properties in Sullivan County, NY with Monticello containing 225 homes for sale, the highest number of listed properties in a single city. There are 54 cities within Sullivan County, NY; homes for sale in those cities, have a range of median values from $586,252 in Claryville to the lowest value of $40,131 in Swan Lake.
    Sold Homes
    The median value for recently sold homes ranges from $881,309 in Pond Eddy to the lowest price of $35,085 in Pond Eddy. There are 54 cities within Sullivan County, NY. Monticello has 106 recently sold homes, the highest number of recently sold properties in a single city. Recently sold homes and properties account for 24.93% of properties in Sullivan County, NY.

      Compare Nearby Cities

      Price
      $/Sqft
      Homes For Sale
      0
      0
      Sullivan County, NY
      $
      $

      Guide for Sullivan County, NY

      Home Buying Guides & Tips
      New York Foreclosure Laws
      Home Buying Guides & Tips
      How To Buy a Piece of Land in Foreclosure
      Home Buying Guides & Tips
      Foreclosure: Cómo Comprar Una Casa En Ejecución Hipotecaria
      Home Buying Guides & Tips
      How to Buy A Foreclosed Home in Chicago
      See More Articles
      New York Foreclosure Laws
      Home Buying Guides & Tips|posted 6 June 2013

      New York Foreclosure Laws

      How To Buy a Piece of Land in Foreclosure
      Home Buying Guides & Tips|posted 3 September 2024

      Foreclosure is a term that can sometimes lead to confusion for those looking to make a real estate investment. In simple terms, it refers to the process where a lender takes possession of a property after the owner fails to keep up with their mortgage payments. When it comes to land, this means that buyers […]

      Foreclosure: Cómo Comprar Una Casa En Ejecución Hipotecaria
      Home Buying Guides & Tips|posted 26 August 2024

      Descubre todo lo que necesitas saber sobre cómo comprar una casa en ejecución hipotecaria.

      How to Buy A Foreclosed Home in Chicago
      Home Buying Guides & Tips|posted 10 June 2024

      Learn how to buy a foreclosed home in Chicago, Illinois.