Cattaraugus County, NY Home Values & Market Trends
The median home price in Cattaraugus County, NY is $174,900. There were 995 home sales in Cattaraugus County, NY over the past 12 months. The median residential Cattaraugus County, NY home value for transactions over the previous year is $82,043. The number of current listings in Cattaraugus County, NY is 1,147, and the percentage of properties for sale is 1147.00%. The county has 139 foreclosures, 5 bank owned properties, 2 headed for auction, and 1,147 properties for sale.
Cattaraugus County, NY Real Estate Market Overview
| City | Median Est. Value | City | Median Est. Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Olean | $ 140,009 $ 95/sqft | South Dayton | $ 128,252 $ 81/sqft |
| Ellicottville | $ 367,558 $ 294/sqft | Hinsdale | $ 200,723 $ 129/sqft |
| Allegany | $ 238,380 $ 133/sqft | Freedom | $ 225,308 $ 169/sqft |
| Gowanda | $ 159,813 $ 121/sqft | Conewango Valley | $ 133,313 $ 87/sqft |
| Franklinville | $ 129,950 $ 89/sqft | Limestone | $ 152,493 $ 100/sqft |
| Salamanca | $ 126,235 $ 79/sqft | Perrysburg | $ 88,351 $ 74/sqft |
| Delevan | $ 211,609 $ 140/sqft | East Otto | $ 221,559 $ 115/sqft |
| Little Valley | $ 189,900 $ 128/sqft | Yorkshire | $ 185,346 $ 160/sqft |
| Cattaraugus | $ 149,900 $ 83/sqft | Farmersville Station | $ 168,296 $ 119/sqft |
| Portville | $ 179,000 $ 109/sqft | Kill Buck | $ 246,251 $ 169/sqft |
| West Valley | $ 218,823 $ 136/sqft | Dayton | $ 166,415 $ 101/sqft |
| Randolph | $ 156,334 $ 99/sqft | Westons Mills | $ -- $ -- |
| Great Valley | $ 238,226 $ 156/sqft | Steamburg | $ -- $ -- |
| Machias | $ 199,900 $ 120/sqft |
Housing Market Summary for Cattaraugus County, NY
| Sep 2025 | September 2026 | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median Listing Price | $159.9K | $165K | 3.19% |
| Median Sold Price | $125.3K | $131.7K | 5.11% |
| Homes For Sale | 694 | 1,125 | 62.10% |
| Homes Sold | 460 | 381 | -17.17% |
Price Per Square Foot
On an average, Single Family homes cost $33 more per sqft than Condos. In comparison with sales price/sqft last week, list price/sqft of Single Family homes increased by 1.93% whereas, list price/sqft of Condos increased by 9.38%.
Recently Sold Homes
Explore recent offers and recently sold homes in Cattaraugus County, NY
Browse Homes in Cattaraugus County, NY
Cattaraugus County, NY home values range from $16,258 to $1,451,665. Ellicottville is the priciest city with a median listing home price of $375,000, and Dayton is most affordable with average house prices of around $119,925.
- Pre-ForeclosurePre-foreclosure homes account for 7.26% of all residential properties in Cattaraugus County, NY with Olean containing 34 pre-foreclosures, the highest number of pre-foreclosure properties in a single city. There are 27 cities within Cattaraugus County, NY; of those cities, the estimated home value for pre-foreclosure homes ranges from $308,575 in Great Valley to the lowest home value of $41,937 in Franklinville.
- Bank OwnedThe median estimated home value of bank owned homes (REO properties) in Cattaraugus County, NY ranges from the highest value of $189,900 in Olean to the lowest value of $35,701 in Cattaraugus. Bank owned homes and properties account for 0.28% of properties in Cattaraugus County, NY. There are 27 cities within Cattaraugus County, NY; Olean containing 2 REO properties, has the highest number of bank owned properties in a single city.
- AuctionsFranklinville has 1 auction properties, the highest number of properties going to auction in a single city in the state of Cattaraugus County, NY. Auction homes and other auction properties account for 0.11% of all properties in Cattaraugus County, NY. There are 27 cities within Cattaraugus County, NY; of those cities, the median estimated home value for homes going to auction ranges from $105,943 in Allegany to the lowest value of $105,943 in Allegany.
Compare Nearby Cities
More Real Estate Resources for Cattaraugus County, NY
Guide for Cattaraugus County, NY
New York Foreclosure Laws
Foreclosure is a term that can sometimes lead to confusion for those looking to make a real estate investment. In simple terms, it refers to the process where a lender takes possession of a property after the owner fails to keep up with their mortgage payments. When it comes to land, this means that buyers […]
Descubre todo lo que necesitas saber sobre cómo comprar una casa en ejecución hipotecaria.
Learn how to buy a foreclosed home in Chicago, Illinois.